Jump to content
How do you handle feedback and revisions from clients or collaborators when composing music for a project?

Recommended Comments

4.9 (441)
  • Music & Audio

Posted

First, I gather as much specific information as possible, including links to what they would like their music to sound like. The better I understand what they want, the less I have to revise.

I usually build into my offer enough time for my client to preview the music before final delivery.  If I have 10 days to finish the music, I will post a preview copy for them to review and collaborate.  I then use their feedback to produce the finished product.

5.0 (1277)
  • Game soundtrack composer
  • Music editor
  • Orchestral composer

Posted

I work like the IT world does with SCRUM/Sprints. 

 

Sprint 1: Make a short 30 second demo for theme to hear. 

 

Sprint 2: Once client approves, do entire composition (maybe its 2 minutes long or a loop, just depends)

 

Sprint 3: Client shown demo quality version of entire composition

 

Sprint 4: Any feedback is integrated into demo version.

 

Sprint 5: Full mix and mastering completed.

 

Sprint 6: Repeat 3-5 until client is happy. 

Sprint 7: Final master and file outputs created. 

5.0 (827)
  • Jingle composer
  • Lead singer
  • Songwriter

Posted

I usually start requesting feedback on the song from the very first stages of development, that way my clients can hear where I'm going with it from the start and share their thoughts at a point where it'll be easy to make adjustments or even start from scratch. That way I make sure that I'm getting the buyer something they'll actually like from the beginning instead of working on a full song that they might not even like the style of.

 

5.0 (229)
  • Film score composer
  • Sound designer

Posted

I see feedback as an opportunity to enhance the project while staying true to the original concept. Balancing client expectations with creative direction is a fine line, but it’s something you learn to navigate over time. Trusting your vision usually leads to the best results, but it’s important to stay open to feedback and understand the client’s vision before starting the work.

4.9 (394)
  • Music & Audio

Posted

When handling feedback and revisions, I focus on open communication and flexibility. I listen carefully to the client’s or collaborator’s input, ensuring I understand their vision and any specific changes they want. I view revisions as a collaborative process, aiming to refine the piece until everyone is satisfied. My goal is to create something that resonates with the project’s goals while maintaining artistic integrity. I also offer unlimited revisions within the scope of the original request, so clients feel confident their ideas will be fully realized.

5.0 (404)
  • Ghost producer
  • Lead singer

Posted

I see feedback and revisions as a key part of the creative process. When working with clients or collaborators, I keep an open mind and treat their input as an opportunity to refine the music and make it even stronger. My goal is to create something that aligns with their vision, so I’m always ready to make adjustments until everyone is satisfied. Clear communication and flexibility are essential in ensuring the final product is something we’re all proud of.

5.0 (458)
  • Film score composer
  • Game soundtrack composer
  • Orchestral composer

Posted

With my extensive experience in the music industry, I approach feedback with an open mind, understanding that it's really important for aligning the music with the project's vision. I listen carefully to the client's or collaborator's suggestions then I make sure I fully understand their perspective.

×
×
  • Create New...